District Court, N.D. Mississippi December 8, 1970, No. CRE 7055 (United States v. Montague)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-12-1970
MEMORANDUM ORDER
READY, Chief Judge.
The motions of William Burdette Montague and Woodrow W. Steen for a severance having been presented to the court, and after consideration of memorandum briefs the court concludes that said motions are not well taken and should be denied. The granting of a severance under Rule 14 of F.R.Crim. P. is in the discretion of the court and is proper only in cases where it is demonstrated that an actual prejudice to the defendants will result from a joint trial.
In this case, three defendants are charged in a one-count indictment with conspiracy to violate the Internal Revenue laws relating to distilled spirits, 18 U.S.C. § 371. The fact that certain overt acts mentioned by name one defendant and not other defendants is not ground for a separate trial. Proof of overt acts on the part of alleged conspirators would be admissible in a sepa*913rate trial no less than a joint trial. It is not at all unusual to have overt acts in a conspiracy indictment specifying by name one or more but less than all of the alleged conspirators.
The court does not find merit in the suggestion that in a joint trial the co-defendants, should they testify, will have their credibility weakened by their interest in the outcome of a joint trial. The interest of a co-defendant, whether in a separate or in a joint trial, will be disclosed to the jury on the basis of his connection claimed to exist with the events testified about. The credibility of a co-defendant who might undertake to testify would not be enhanced through separate trial of each defendant. Moreover, the suggestion that a co-defendant might testify in a separate trial is not an adequate demonstration that the co-defendant would actually testify in a separate trial, or that he would not testify in a joint trial, nor for that matter that any co-defendant would, in fact, be called on to give testimony in any trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit