Court of Appeals for the First Circuit August 3, 1970, Nos. 7540, 7553 (Nashua Corp. v. RCA Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-08-1970

COFFIN, Circuit Judge.

The principal question presented by these cross appeals is whether the district court erred in holding invalid as obvious an RCA patent — Greig patent 3,052,540 [hereinafter sometimes patent ’540] — which specified 29 organic dyes which increase the sensitivity of the electrophotographic copying paper used in many office copying machines.

Harold Greig, a scientist employed by RCA, obtained the patent in 1962 on the basis of discoveries made in 1953. Soon thereafter RCA granted a license to various companies, including Nashua Corporation, to use its patent in the manufacture of electrophotographic copying paper. Nashua paid royalties for some four years, until it served notice on RCA of its belief in the invalidity of the patent and continued using dyes similar to those set forth in patent ’540 without paying royalties. Nashua brought suit for a declaration of patent invalidity and a refund of four years’ royalties; RCA counterclaimed for infringement. The district court held that the patent was invalid and thus not infringed but that Nashua was not entitled to a refund of royalties. Nashua Corporation v. RCA Corporation, 307 F.Supp. 152 (D.N.H.1969). RCA appeals from the first two determinations, Nashua from the third.

The district court’s opinion contains a comprehensive description of the perti*222nent technology and the processes underlying the contested patent. Briefly, one method of copying original documents by electrophotography involves coating the copy paper so that it will receive and retain in darkness an electrostatic charge (the quality of “dark resistivity”) and then exposing the electrostatically-charged paper to light, thereby causing the charges to disappear from the exposed portions of the copy paper (the quality of “photoconductivity”). The area which retains the electrostatic charge — a latent image of the document being copied — is then developed by application of a fine powder which is attracted to the remaining charges.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.