Oregon Supreme Court March 10, 1971 (Colwell v. Chernabaeff)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1971

DENECKE, J.

The defendants are attempting to appeal from a default decree of strict foreclosure of a land sale contract. The defendants contend the trial court erred in entering the order of default and the decree and in refusing to set aside the default and decree.

After a hearing defendants’ demurrer to plaintiffs’ complaint was overruled on May 29, 1969, the defendants were given 10 days “to further plead.” Notice of such order was given to defendants’ attorney. On June 4, 1969, defendants’ attorney served and filed a document captioned, “Notice,” in which it was stated that defendants had never been served with any order overruling the demurrer, defendants moved to strike certain paragraphs of plaintiffs’ complaint, and requested the taking of the depositions of certain witnesses. On June 26, 1969, plaintiffs filed

*375

a motion asking for an order requiring the defendants to show cause why they should not confess judgment to a decree of strict foreclosure. Such order was issued, setting July 9, 1969, for the show cause hearing, and all the documents were served upon defendants’ counsel. The hearing was held at the time set. No one appeared for defendants. The court entered an order of default for defendants’ failure to answer and entered a decree of strict foreclosure. On July 15, 1969, defendant Sam Chernabaeff filed a motion to set aside the default. This was denied in February 1970 after a hearing.

Defendants cannot appeal from the default decree for the reason that defendants are attempting to appeal from a decree given “for want of an answer” which is not appealable. OES 19.020.

①

“It is settled in this state that while an appeal will lie from a void decree when taken by default, it will not lie from one which is merely voidable or erroneous:

Smith v. Ellendale Mill Co., 4

Or. 70;

Trullenger v. Todd,

5 Or. 36;

Askren v. Squire,

29 Or. 228 (45 Pac. 779).”

Oregon Lumber & Fuel Co. v. Hall,

76 Or 138, 140, 148 P 61 (1915).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.