Court of Appeals of Georgia February 5, 1971, 45832 (Smith v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1971

Deen, Judge.

The testimony elicited from the State’s witness Cleghorn is to the effect that he had occasion to talk with the three co-defendants in the jail after their arrest; that he advised them of their rights; that thereafter the younger Smith boy freely and voluntarily made a statement that he and the other defendants had gone into five or six places during that afternoon, including the Jarrett home and the homes of other named persons. On cross examination, Cleghorn was not interrogated as to the details of the alleged statement, but he was questioned by counsel as to whether such statement was oral or in writing, whether the witness had not positively testified in a former case that he got no statement from any of the defendants, and whether the statement was made in the presence of the defendant. To the last question the response was negative. Thereafter, counsel moved to rule out

*271

all testimony relating to the statement of the co-defendant and the court overruled the motion.

(a) The admission of the testimony was error. "The testimony of an investigating officer concerning the in-custody narration of past events by a person shown by the evidence to have been a conspirator with the accused . . . made after police officers had apprehended the accused, the narrator and their companion, and had thus effectively terminated the conspiracy, where the narration is not shown as made in the presence of the accused, was inadmissible hearsay, and it was prejudicial error to allow the jury to consider such testimony.”

Green v. State,

115 Ga. App. 685 (2) (155 SE2d 655).

(b) A motion to rule out testimony illegally admitted, even without objection, is never too late until the cause is finally submitted to the jury.

Blount v. Beall,

95 Ga. 182 (4) (22 SE 52);

McCalman v. State,

121 Ga. 491 (49 SE 609). These cases are cited in

Rushin v. State,

63 Ga. App.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.