Court of Appeals of Georgia May 21, 1971, 46067 (Hall v. Westmoreland, Hall & Bryan)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1971

Quillian, Judge.

The plaintiffs contend that the trial judge properly granted their motion for summary judgment since Exhibit "A” was a negotiable instrument and that they were holders in due course to whom any defenses interposed by the defendant were not applicable.

*811

One of the requirements of a negotiable instrument is that it contain the time honored "words of negotiability,” such as pay to the order of or pay to bearer. This was inherent in our law prior to the enactment of the Commercial Code. See

Pryor v. American Trust &c. Co.,

15 Ga. App. 822, 825 (84 SE 312);

Metropolitan Discount Co. v. Wardlaw,

37 Ga. App. 423 (2) (140 SE 525);

Chandler v. Smith,

147 Ga. 637 (1) (95 SE 223). The Commercial Code continues this practice by now stating: "Any writing to be a negotiable instrument within this Article must ... be payable to order or to bearer.”

Code Ann.

§ 109A-3 — 104 (1) (d) (Ga. L. 1962, pp. 156, 239). See

Code Ann.

§§ 109A-3 — 110 and 109A-3 — 111 (Ga. L. 1962, pp. 156, 242, 243). In the absence of such language, Exhibit "A” would not be a negotiable instrument.

Even if Exhibit "A” be considered a negotiable instrument, plaintiffs failed to meet the requirements of a holder in due course. Under the Commercial Code, the payee may be a holder in due course.

Code Ann.

§ 109A-3 — 302 (2) (Ga. L. 1962, pp. 156, 252). However, this does not mean he is per se a holder in due course; for he must meet all the requisites outlined in

Code Ann.

§ 109A-3 — 302. See also

Code Ann.

§§ 109A-3 — 303 and 109A-3— 304 (Ga. L. 1962, pp. 156, 253). Furthermore, even a holder in due course takes the instrument free of all defenses

only

"of any party to the instrument with whom the holder has not dealt.”

Code Ann.

§ 109A-3 — 305 (2) (Ga. L. 1962, pp. 156, 255). Here, the plaintiffs failed to show they occupied the status of a holder in due course, or to establish they were not a party with whom the defendant dealt in this transaction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.