District Court, W.D. Michigan November 12, 1971, Civ. A. 6250 (Armour and Company v. Ball)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-1971

OPINION

FOX, Chief Judge.

Plaintiffs Armour and Company, Wilson and Co., Inc., and Geo. A. Hormel and Company brought this action against B. Dale Ball, the Director of the Michigan Department of Agriculture, and Ronald M. Leach, Acting Chief of the Food Inspection Division of the Michigan Department of Agriculture. They request the court to enjoin the defendants from enforcing the marketing, labeling, packaging and ingredient provisions of the Michigan Comminuted Meat Law, P.A.1952, No. 228, M.S.A. § 12.964 (1) et seq., M.C.L.A. § 289.581 et seq. and further ask the court to declare the Michigan Comminuted Meat law unconstitutional and therefore, unenforceable against the plaintiffs.

*940

The preamble to the Michigan Com-minuted Meat Act states that it is an act:

providing for the protection of the public health and the prevention of fraud and deception by prohibiting the manufacture, sale, the offering for sale or exposing for sale or having in possession with intent to sell, sausage, meat loaf, hamburger, chili con carne, liver sausage, head cheese, sulze, blood sausage, New York (New England) (pressed luncheon), and tongue sausage, that is adulterated or deleterious or not in compliance with this act; defining the mentioned products and other terms used; providing for licensing; regulating labeling and advertising; prescribing penalties for violations of this act; and repealing certain acts and parts of acts.

Thus, the act focuses on the labeling and marketing of processed meats.

The United States Congress has likewise passed an act, the Federal Wholesome Meat Act, 21 U.S.C.App. § 601 et seq., regulating the labeling, marketing, inspection and other aspects of the meat industry.

The plaintiffs attack the Michigan Comminuted Meat Act on the basis of the Federal Wholesome Meat Act, claiming that the federal act entirely preempts the field of meat labeling and ingredient requirements.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.