Supreme Court of Minnesota March 26, 1971, 42254 (Wiley v. Hoven)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-1971

Pee Curiam.

This is a contribution claim arising out of an intersection collision. The jury found both drivers negligent but only the negligence of Lorraine J. Hoven to be a proximate cause of the accident. She and defendant Luverne G. Hoven, owner of the car which she was driving, appeal from the judgment which denies them contribution against third-party defendant Thomas Wiley.

At the time of the accident, on May 18,1967, Thomas Wiley was operating his father’s car, with his mother as a passenger, proceeding south on Highway No. 47 in Fridley. Defendant Lorraine J. Hoven approached and entered Highway No. 47 on 49th Street, driving in a westerly direction. At that time, Highway No. 47, the through highway, was in the process of construction. Mrs. Hoven entered and crossed Highway No. 47 in the path of Thomas Wiley, and the collision resulted.

The jury returned a verdict of $12,000 in favor of Mrs. Wiley and Oscar Wiley, who owned the Wiley vehicle. The only issue is whether

*484

the negligence of Thomas Wiley was as a matter of law a proximate cause of the accident. We hold that it was not.

Defendants Hoven argue that the evidence compels a finding that Thomas Wiley exceeded the speed limit and failed to keep a proper lookout, and that such negligence constituted a proximate cause of the collision. In addition, they complain that the instruction on forfeiture of right-of-way for excessive speed left the impression that it applied only when one having the right-of-way was traveling

over

the statutory limit.

There was evidence that the speed limit at this intersection was 35 miles an hour, but whether the limit was posted at the time of the accident was in dispute. A police officer testified that he saw no sign before or after the accident. Estimates of Wiley’s speed ranging from 35 miles an hour to 50 miles an hour were made by several witnesses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.