Supreme Court of Iowa April 9, 1971, 54425 (State v. Straw)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1971

BECKER, Justice.

Defendant was charged by county attorney’s information with the crime of sale of beer to a minor in that he “did unlawfully and willfully sell * * * to Thomas G. VanSyoc, a minor, * * * ” contrary to section 124.20 of the Iowa Code. Trial to jury resulted in conviction. Defendant appeals. Reversed and remanded.

The facts are brief and largely uncontested. On March 31, 1970, Thomas Van-Syoc was 16 years old, about 6 feet tall, weighed 190 pounds, wore his hair rather long and had a goatee and long sideburns.

At the time of the sale defendant was an employee of the Circle Tap. His main duties were preparation and serving of food but he sometimes sold beer to customers. He had been so employed for about three months and had been told not to guess at anybody’s age but to check their identification.

VanSyoc simply walked in, asked to buy a six-pack of beer, received the beer and paid for it without being questioned as to his age. He testified he had been in the Circle Tap once about a year before and had only had a pizza at that time.

*814

Defendant Straw said the reasons he sold the beer without questioning were that he recognized VanSyoc as a customer, had seen him in the place before (possibly 3 times), he thought defendant was 21 or over. When defendant saw VanSyoc at the bar he thought VanSyoc had been there for awhile and had been served before.

VanSyoc was working with the police at the time he bought the beer. He had an identification card with him that showed he was 16 years old. He was told to show the card if requested to do so and not to argue or importune if there was a refusal to sell the beer to him. No identification was requested.

I. The main controversies in this case center on a 1965 amendment to section 124.20(3), Code, 1971. The statute formerly prohibited sale of beer to minors without reference to knowledge on the part of the seller. Our construction of the statute (before amendment) left little doubt as to its meaning. In State v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.