Michigan Court of Appeals March 25, 1971, Docket 9065 (People v. Sheehy)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-03-1971

T. M. Burns, J.

On February 5, 1970, defendant was convicted by a jury of the crime of rape.

1

He was sentenced on February 18, 1970, to a term of from three to ten years in the state prison. Defendant appeals as of right.

Defendant first contends that the trial court should not have permitted the victim to testify that just prior to committing the rape charged, her assailant committed gross indeceny,

i.e.

penetration

per os,

a criminal act in itself under MCLA § 750-.338b (Stat Ann 1954 Rev § 28.570[2]). The trial

*630

court ruled that the evidence was admissible as part of the

res gestae.

In

People

v.

Savage

(1923), 225 Mich 84, 86, the Supreme Court stated:

“It is elementary that the acts, conduct and demeanor of a person charged with crime at the time of, or shortly before or after the offense is claimed to have been committed, may be shown as a part of the

res gestae.

Proof of such acts is not rendered inadmissible by the fact that they may tend to show the commission of another crime.”

However, to be admitted as part of the

res gestae,

the facts to be proven must not only be proximate in time to the principal fact, they must also illustrate and characterize the principal fact:

“ ‘No inflexible rule has ever been and probably never can be adopted as to what is a part of the

res gestae.

It must be determined largely in each case by the peculiar facts and circumstances incident thereto; but it may be stated as a fixed rule that, included in the

res gestae

are the facts which so illustrate and characterize the principal fact as to constitute the whole one transaction, and render the latter necessary to exhibit the former in its proper effect.’

Chicago & Erie Ry. Co.

v.

Cummings

(1899), 24 Ind App 192, 209 (53 NE 1026, 1031).”

2

In view of these decisions, the trial court was correct in concluding that an act of gross indecency, committed immediately prior to the forced act of sexual intercourse, was a part of the

res gestae

of the crime of rape.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.