Wisconsin Supreme Court June 25, 1971, State 41 (Sprague v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-06-1971
Connor T. Hansen, J.
We consider three issues to be raised on this appeal:
1. Did the trial court err in refusing to permit the introduction of testimony concerning the defendant’s history of epilepsy, to negate intent, in the first portion of the sequential trial ?
2. Did the defendant prove he was insane at the time of the offense?
3. Is the defendant entitled to a new trial in the interest of justice ?
Intent.
During the guilt portion of the trial, several attempts were made by counsel for the defendant to introduce testimony concerning the defendant’s history of epilepsy. Objections to such testimony were sustained by the trial court.
Verdicts submitted to the jury included verdicts of first- and second-degree murder.
*95
Counsel for the defendant contends that the attempts to introduce testimony concerning the defendant’s prior history of epilepsy were for the purpose of negating the intent necessary for a finding of first-degree murder, and that it was error for the trial court to refuse to permit the introduction of this testimony in the guilt portion of the trial.
The question whether medical evidence which is material to the issue of sanity may also be introduced in the guilt portion of the trial to negate intent was considered by this court in
Curl v. State
(1968), 40 Wis. 2d 474, 162 N. W. 2d 77. In that case the defendant was tried for the offense of armed robbery. This court held that it was not error to exclude evidence of the defendant’s prior mental condition in the guilt portion of the trial. The court stated:
. . To bifurcate a trial is to separate completely the issue of lack of accountability due to insanity from the issue of whether the crime was committed. If the testimony of earlier hospitalizations and mental condition at such earlier times is also material on the issue of guilt, there would be no reason to hold split trials. All testimony as to mental condition would be in the record before the trial on insanity began.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit