Michigan Court of Appeals February 19, 1971, Docket 9703 (Braidwood v. Harmon)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-1971

Levin, J.

Plaintiffs, Harold and Wanda Braid-wood, executed a promissory note secured by a mortgage on their home in favor of Harold Braid-wood’s uncle, Clarence L. Pinel. After Pinel’s death, the Braidwoods commenced this action claiming that Pinel had, during his lifetime, made a gift of the note and mortgage to them. They asked that the note and mortgage be cancelled and that Pinel’s administrator be enjoined from foreclosing the mortgage.

After hearing the evidence offered by both parties, the judge, as trier of fact, found that the Braidwoods had failed to prove a gift

inter vivos

and entered an order dismissing their complaint.

*52

Among the issues is whether the Braidwoods’ claim may be proved orally. It is also necessary to consider the recently amended dead man’s statute.

Pinel went to live in the home of his nephew, plaintiff Harold Braidwood, in 1955 or 1956. Shortly after his arrival Pinel paid off the mortgage on the Braidwood home. In return the Braidwoods executed and delivered to Pinel a note and mortgage dated January 7, 1956 for $8,800, payable $50 a month, including interest at 4%

per annum.

James Braidwood, Harold’s brother, testified that a short time after the note and mortgage were executed Pinel handed the instruments to Harold and said, “As long as I’m living I want you to pay me and when I die it is your home free and clear”. A sister of Mrs. Braidwood testified that Pinel had told her and her husband, “that he had signed the home over to Mr. Braidwood at his death, the home would be his and everything that he owned”. Photocopies of the note and mortgage were attached to the Braidwoods’ complaint filed when this action was commenced, and the originals were offered in evidence by the Braidwoods.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.