Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit January 20, 1971, 19760, 19766 (Sweetarts, an Oregon Corporation v. Sunline, Inc., a Missouri Corporation, and Menlo F. Smith, (Two Cases))

Also known as

United States · · · 20-01-1971

BRIGHT, Circuit Judge.

These two appeals arise out of trademark infringement litigation which be

*707

gan in 1964. The appeal in No. 19760 presents the question of whether plaintiff Sweetarts, an Oregon candy manufacturer, has established sufficient market penetration in eight states through the distribution of candy products bearing its common-law technical trademark “SweeTarts” to entitle it to injunctive protection prohibiting the defendant, Sunline, Inc. (Sunline),

1

from using the same “SweeTarts” mark on the latter’s candy products in those eight states. This court previously held that the extent of plaintiff’s market penetration in ten states presented a factual question and remanded the matter to the district court with instructions to make that determination. Sweetarts v. Sunline, Inc., 380 F.2d 923 (8th Cir. 1967). On remand, the district court determined that eight of the ten states in question constituted part of the plaintiff’s effective market area and enjoined Sunline from using the trademark “SweeTarts” on its candy products in those states. Sweet-arts v. Sunline, Inc., 299 F.Supp. 572 (E.D.Mo.1969). Defendant Sunline prosecutes an appeal from the district court’s award of injunctive relief to the plaintiff. For reasons stated below, we reverse.

In No. 19766, plaintiff Sweetarts appeals from the district court’s refusal to order an accounting and to award the plaintiff damages, including additional attorney’s fees, after the court found the defendants in civil contempt for using a confusingly similar trademark in three states already decreed by this court to be within the plaintiff’s effective market area. The issues presented on the appeal by Sweetarts are completely separate from the questions raised by Sunline in No. 19760. The district court considered all of the issues raised on these two appeals in a single opinion.

Sweetarts, supra,

299 F.Supp. 572.

We turn first to Sunline’s appeal in No. 19760.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.