Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit November 3, 1971, 71-1074 (Shirley McGowen v. The Travelers Insurance Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-11-1971

combined-opinion

448 F.2d 1315 Shirley McGOWEN, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. The TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-Appellee. No. 71-1074 Summary Calendar.* United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. September 28, 1971. Rehearing Denied November 3, 1971. B. A. Britt, Jr., Harry B. Friedman, Harkness, Friedman & Kusin, Texarkana, Tex., for plaintiff-appellant. Howard Waldrop, Atchley, Russell, Hutchinson & Waldrop, Texarkana, Tex., for defendant-appellee. Before JOHN R. BROWN, Chief Judge, and INGRAHAM and RONEY, Circuit Judges. JOHN R. BROWN, Chief Judge: 1 We are called upon here to determine whether under a Texas life policy the death of the assured was an "accident." The District Court directed a verdict against the beneficiary and in favor of the insurance company. We affirm. 2 The assured was John M. He and his wife Shirley, the beneficiary, had gone to a party hosted by Shirley's niece. There was no evidence that there was any ill feeling between Shirley and John until John became irate about the way Shirley was dancing. John insisted that he and Shirley go home at once. 3 Trying to comply, Shirley got in their car and backed it out. Seemingly unnerved by her husband, she hit the curb. John told her to get out of the car. John then got in, drove a short distance, stopped, and emerged with a knife and started moving toward his wife. Understandably frightened, Shirley turned and ran toward the niece's house. She yelled to her niece imploring her to have John's brother, Columbus, come to the rescue. 4 Columbus quickly arrived on the scene and tried to calm John down. John returned to the car but the fray was now just beginning. John again came from the car wielding his knife at Shirley and Columbus. Columbus pulled a gun and shot John in the stomach. In apparent pain John grabbed himself and pleaded with Shirley for help. This offer was refused, for John still was brandishing his knife.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.