Circuit Court of the 17th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Broward County February 2, 1971, No. 68-5540 (Wometco Enterprises, Inc. v. Broward County)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-1971

STEPHEN R. BOOHER, Circuit Judge.

Final judgment: This matter is before the court on final hearing. The issues having been clearly defined, briefed, and argued by counsel for the parties, and the court having carefully examined the record and being otherwise fully advised in the premises, it is ordered and adjudged as follows —

I.

The court has jurisdiction over the subject matter, specifically granted by statute, §200.10, Florida Statutes (1967). The cause is here on certiorari to review a decision of the Broward County Commission sitting ex officio as a board of equalization for the year 1968. Petitioners alleged serious constitutional problems with the board of equalization proceedings. On either basis there is a sufficient predicate for circuit court certiorari jurisdiction.

II.

The court has jurisdiction over the parties. This specific question was originally before the court on the motion to dismiss or quash of respondent Broward County Commission, filed September 20, 1968. At a subsequent hearing,- this motion was denied on all grounds save one — petitioners’ failure to join indispensable parties. In the absence of clear and specific authority in support of this phase of the respondent’s motion, the court reserved ruling on that question and, by order entered May 15, 1970, requested briefs and further argument. Briefs-in-main were filed by both parties. A reply brief was submitted by petitioners. Additional oral argument was noticed and heard. After lengthy consideration of authorities and due deliberation over the issues raised and presented by counsel *29for the parties, the court concluded that respondent’s motion should be denied for the reasons set out in the order of August 3, 1970, extracted below.

1. Nature of the proceedings. The instant case is not an original suit in equity challenging an assessment or tax, where the necessary parties defendant are prescribed by statute. See chapter 196, Florida Statutes (1967); §200.40, Florida Statutes (1967).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.