Court of Appeals of Texas January 15, 1971, No. 17161 (Howle v. Camp Amon Carter)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1971

OPINION

BREWSTER, Justice.

This suit was brought by John W. Howie, individually and as next friend of his minor son, Johnny Howie, against the Young Men’s Christian Association of Fort Worth and Tarrant County and against Camp Carter, a branch of the Young Men’s Christian Association of Fort Worth and Tarrant County, to recover damages for injuries sustained by the minor when struck in the eye by a sinker or weight attached to a fishing line being cast *625by a fellow camper while they were both in attendance at a camping session at Camp Carter. As a result of being hit the boy lost the sight of an eye.

Recovery was sought from the two defendants named on the theory that defendants’ employees (supervisors at the camp) committed negligent acts or omissions which proximately caused the injuries.

The defendants urged as a defense the fact that defendants were nonprofit organizations and contended that the doctrine of charitable immunity prevented them from being in any way liable to plaintiffs.

The defendants filed a motion for summary judgment urging this defense and the trial court sustained the motion, rendering a take nothing judgment in favor of defendants and this appeal is from that judgment.

On the appeal the plaintiffs’ brief urges four (4) points of error. During the argument before this Court counsel for appellants stated to this Court that they waived their third point, same relating to appel-lees’ evidence tending to prove that defendants were nonprofit organizations. Such counsel requested that this Court on this appeal assume that defendants were nonprofit or charitable organizations. For these reasons we will make no further mention of appellants’ third point.

Appellants contend in Point 1 that the charitable immunity doctrine is not at this time the law in Texas because it was abolished by the Supreme Court of Texas in the case of Watkins v. Southcrest Baptist Church, 399 S.W.2d 530 (Tex.Sup., 1966).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.