Supreme Court of Georgia November 18, 1971, 26712 (Tomlinson v. Patrick)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-11-1971

lead-opinion

Hawes, Justice.

1. The court did not err in overruling appellants’ motion to dismiss the complaint.

2. Contracts of the character with which we are here dealing are generally regarded by the courts as being of two kinds. In one kind the complaining party may be shown to have agreed with the decedent to go into the home of the decedent to nurse and to give "personal, affectionate and considerate attention, such as could not readily be procured elsewhere.” Such services are regarded as being so personal in character that they are of the kind that can normally only be rendered by a close relative out of love and affection for the one thus ministered to, and are of such character that their value cannot be equated with money. Potts v. Mathis, 149 Ga. 367, 370 (100 SE 110); Brogdon v. Hogan, 189 Ga. 244, 250 (5 SE2d 657); Johns v. Nix, 196 Ga. 417 (3) (26 SE2d 526). Upon proof of this kind of contract, it is unnecessary to show the monetary value of services rendered in performance of the agreement by the plaintiff.

The other kind of contract is one where the agreement is merely to render for the deceased such services as might readily be procured by the deceased by employing another to perform them in exchange for the payment of money. In such case, in order for the plaintiff to recover damages for the breach of an agreement or to have specific performance, it is necessary that the plaintiff prove the value of the services which were actually rendered. If the plaintiff’s evidence proved the existence of any agreement to go into the home of the deceased or into the home of the deceased and her husband before her husband’s death and render the kind of personal services intended to be embodied in contracts of the first kind above referred to, it failed to show performance of that kind of contract. It is true that the evidence shows that Mrs. Bridges called Mr. and Mrs. Patrick to come from Lakeland to Tampa to assist her with Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.