Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 1, 1971 (Silverman v. Alcoa Plaza Associates)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1971
lead-opinion
Murphy, J.
The appellant had deposited the sum of $15,400 with the respondent on account of the purchase of shares of stock and a proprietary lease in a co-operative apartment. The total purchase price was to be $154,000. By reason of what was described as “uncertain business condition” the appellant defaulted. The facts are not in dispute. Some time later on learning that respondent had sold the shares and proprietary lease to the apartment to another for the same price the appellant instituted suit to recover the down payment. Respondent moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint on the theory that plaintiff had willfully breached the contract involving the sale of real estate resulting in the forfeiture of the deposit. Appellant opposed the motion and sought to restrict the loss of her deposit to the actual damages provable by the respondent, if any. The lower court held that the stock could not be characterized as “ goods ” under article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code but rather would fall within an area not regulated by statute where decisional law has established that the seller is entitled to retain the deposit citing Kaplan v. Scheiner (1 A D 2d 329). Having determined that the transaction was one involving the sale of real property, the lower court made its decision in accordance with the law of damages relating to realty.
*168If the stock and proprietary lease in a co-operative are considered realty, the seller (respondent) is entitled to retain by way of forfeiture the down payment, without proof of damages. This rule of damages is peculiar to actions involving real property. Perhaps it is the involved nature or uniqueness of real property that justifies such a rule, for it cannot be argued that courts generally are loath to enforce forfeiture and penalty clauses, and that only in specific instances (such as damages relating to the breach of a contract of the sale of realty) are they enforced.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit