Ohio Supreme Court June 30, 1971, No. 70-493 (Capello v. City of Mayfield Heights)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1971

lead-opinion

O’Neill, C. J.

The determinative question in this cause is whether the trial court erred in basing its decision solely on the transcript of the proceedings before the Board of Zoning Appeals.

In basing its holding on the transcript, the trial court *5concluded that the board’s decision was “supported by reliable and probative evidence.” It is, therefore, necessary to determine if the transcript contains such evidence.

Appellees state that the transcript “does contain a complete record of all the evidence and testimony submitted by appellants” to the board. Appellees admit, however, that the testimony of appellants’ witness, Vince Capello, Jr., was not made under oath.

In Arcaro Bros. Builders, Inc., v. Zoning Board of Appeals (1966), 7 Ohio St. 2d 32, also a zoning case, the chairman of a zoning board of appeals refused, at a hearing, to permit witnesses to be sworn. The decision of the zoning board there was appealed to the Court of Common Pleas which, without taking additional evidence, affirmed the decision of the board. In the appeal to this court, it was held that, since R. C. 2317.30 requires a witness to be sworn before testifying, the record contained no evidence and, therefore, the decision of the board “was not supported ‘by the preponderance of substantial, reliable and probative evidence * * V ”

That holding is applicable here, inasmuch as there was no sworn testimony taken at the hearing before the board. In fact, no evidence was offered by appellees in opposition to appellants’ application at the hearing.

Appellees argue, nonetheless, that by not requesting that the witness be sworn at the hearing, appellants waived that right and that the burden of presenting evidence at the hearing was upon appellants.

It is apparent that for a court to find that an administrative order is supported by reliable and probative evidence “* * # such evidence must not only exist but must be in the record in order to support an affirmance.” Doelker v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.