Michigan Supreme Court July 26, 1972, 4 December Term 1971, Docket No. 53,232-1/2 (People v. Tanner)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1972

T. M. Kavanagh, C. J.

Charged with first-degree murder, defendant pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the fifth day of trial. He was thereafter sentenced to serve 14 years, 11 months to 15 years in prison. The Court of Appeals denied defendant’s application for leave January 6, 1971. We granted leave. 384 Mich 825 (1971).

Defendant presents three issues for review which attack the sentence imposed as: (1) an abuse of discretion; (2) cruel or unusual punishment; and (3) a violation of due process.

By their 1902 amendment of the Constitution of 1850, the people first provided the legislature with the power to establish indeterminate sentences following the Supreme Court’s holding in

People

v

Cummings,

88 Mich 249 (1891), that any such power must be established in the organic law. Subsequent to that amendment, in

People

v

Cook,

147 Mich 127

*687

(1907), the Court referred to and adopted the reasoning- of the minority opinion in

In re Manaca,

146 Mich 697 (1906), wherein Justice Moore laid to rest all questions of the constitutionality of indeterminate sentencing*. We likewise hold that our present indeterminate sentence act is not constitutionally infirm as providing cruel or unusual punishment or as denying due process.

Defendant’s remaining* issue concerns the application of the statute to his sentence. Generally, in the past, this Court has refused to review sentences in any context, typically observing, as in

People

v

Guillett,

342 Mich 1, 9 (1955), that :

“It is sufficient to say that the sentence was within the maximum provided by statute.”

Even in

People

v

Murray,

72 Mich 10, 17 (1888), though the Court opined that the 23-year-old defendant’s sentence of 50 years for carnal knowledge of a female under 14 was excessive as unwarranted by the record, and all agreed that the trial court had abused its discretion in so pronouncing sentence, a new trial was ordered for other reasons.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.