Wisconsin Supreme Court October 3, 1972, 140 (Mastercraft Paper Products, Inc. v. Freightways)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-1972

Hanley, J.

There are five issues presented on this appeal:

(1) Did the trial court properly instruct the jury relating to Consolidated’s duty as a carrier;

(2) Was it error for the court not to have submitted an instruction relating to the United States Uniform Bill of Lading Act, regarding “shippers load and count;”

(3) Was it error for the trial court to submit an instruction on

res ipsa loquitur;

and, if not, was the instruction improperly worded;

(4) Was it error for the trial court to insert questions in the verdict relating to loss of use and other forms of consequential damages; and

(5) Was the jury’s verdict perverse because it returned only a portion of the amount of actual shipping costs ?

*679

Instruction as to common-law duty.

Appellant contends that the court improperly instructed the jury on its common-law liability. The instruction given by the court reads as follows:

“The rule of law is that common carriers of freight such as the defendant, Consolidated Freightways, is responsible for any damage to any shipment made upon its lines, except damages that were occasioned by an act of God which is something that occurs without the intervention or control of man. . . .”

The appellant argues that a carrier is also not responsible for the ordinary jerks and jars of train movement, citing

Best v. Great Northern Ry. Co.

(1915), 159 Wis. 429, 150 N. W. 484.

The omission of this exception in the instruction was not error since there was no evidence of the press being shipped by rail. The press was shipped the entire distance by truck. Furthermore, appellant did not object to the instruction until his motion for a new trial. If “. . . instructions given are not erroneous as a misstatement of the law but are incomplete, it is the duty of counsel to object at the time the instruction is given. . . .”

Savina v. Wisconsin Gas Co.

(1967), 36 Wis. 2d 694, 702, 154 N. W. 2d 237.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.