Court of Appeals of Texas May 25, 1972, 17881 (Martin v. Lott)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-05-1972

GUITTARD, Justice.

This appeal is from a summary judgment denying plaintiff Stanley Martin specific’ performance of a letter agreement concerning repurchase of a certain overriding royalty he had previously conveyed to Patricia Patterson, deceased. The court ruled that by accepting payments made to him as life tenant under Miss Patterson’s will, plaintiff made a binding election which bars him from enforcing the letter agreement, We hold that plaintiff was required to elect, but that such an election has not been established as a matter of law, and we remand for further proceedings.

The letter agreement, dated August 7, 1961, is as follows :

“Miss Patricia Patterson 1426 Fidelity Union Building Dallas 1, Texas

Dear Pat:

In consideration of your willingness to purchase one-half of my one-fourth of the overriding royalty on the Carroll, Dempsey-Montooth, Ellison, Fry Lease and LeForce Lease, I agree that:

Any time you wish to sell your interest, I will re-purchase it for $2,575.00, minus all payments which have been paid thereon from date of purchase until date of re-sale to me.

Sincerely,

/s/ Stanley E. Martin STANLEY E. MARTIN

In consideration of your guarantee of re-purchase of the above described one-half of one-fourth overriding royalty, I agree that:

I will not sell or transfer this interest to anyone without first offering it to you. The purchase price to you shall be not more than four times my purchase price, minus all payments which have been paid thereon from date of my purchase to date of re-sale to you.

/s/ Patricia Patterson PATRICIA PATTERSON”

Miss Patterson died October 31, 1970 after receiving more than $16,000 in royalty payments. Her will leaves all income from her oil royalties to plaintiff Martin for his life, with remainder to Mary Lott and Theda Vannoy. Mary Lott qualified as executrix.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.