Michigan Court of Appeals January 25, 1972, Docket 10777 (People v. McDaniels)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-01-1972
Per Curiam.
Defendant Horace McDaniels was convicted by a jury of armed robbery, MCLA 750-.529; MSA 28.797. He appeals as of right.
On appeal defendant charges that the trial court erred in failing to instruct the jury on. lesser included offenses.
In
People
v
Stevens,
9 Mich App 531, 533-534 (1968), this Court stated:
“Where a request has been made to charge on a lesser included offense, the duty of the trial judge is determined by the evidence.
“If evidence has been presented to support a conviction of the lesser offense, the requested instructions must be given; failure to do so would constitute error.
People
v
Jones
(1935), 273 Mich 430.”
In the case at bar, the defendant in the first instance, during a conference on jury instructions, effectively waived instructions on lesser included offenses. After the conference, court adjourned until the following day. The next morning, before the jury retired to deliberate, defendant changed his position and requested that the jury be instructed on lesser included offenses. The trial court denied this request. Had no more transpired, a denial of this request would require reversal, as the record shows no weapon was found upon the defendant at the time of his arrest which occurred immediately after
*176
the robbery and at least two witnesses testified that they saw no weapon upon the defendant. The evidence was sufficient to entitle defendant to a charge on lesser included offenses. However, approximately an hour after the jury retired to deliberate, the jury sent the court a note asking “Are we to decide whether it was armed robbery only?” Thereupon the court ordered the jury returned to the courtroom and the foreman of the jury was asked to explain what the note meant. He stated:
“There was a discussion between two of the jurors,' or maybe three, as to what it — whether we had to find whether it was an armed robbery, or a robbery, or not guilty. Is that clear enough, sir?
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit