Michigan Court of Appeals February 24, 1972, Docket 11270 (Korash v. Livonia)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-02-1972
Danhof, J.
Plaintiffs are the owners of approximately 15 acres of land in the City of Livonia. In March 1969, the property was zoned, to allow multiple dwellings or apartment houses. In March 1969, petitions were filed with the city clerk, pursuant to
*628
the Charter of the City of Livonia, to amend the zoning ordinance of the City of Livonia. The initiatory petitions were found to be in proper form and to meet the requirements of the city charter of the defendant city, and subsequently, on September 29, 1969, at a special election the zoning amendment was approved. The effect of the zoning ordinance was to prohibit the multiple dwellings on the plaintiffs’ property. Thereafter, plaintiffs commenced suit in the Wayne County Circuit Court requesting injunctive relief, mandamus, and- declaratory and summary judgments. The trial judge found that the case involved purely a legal issue, with no facts being in dispute, and granted a declaratory judgment to the plaintiffs declaring the ordinance adopted by the initiatory petitions to be invalid. The trial court determined the instant case to be controlled by the decision of this Court in
Elliott
v
City of Clawson,
21 Mich App 363 (1970).
Both parties concede. that if this case is controlled by
Elliott, supra,
the trial judge should be affirmed. Defendants, however, have made a vigorous argument that the decision in
Elliott, supra,
is incorrect and that this panel should not follow the decision reached in
Elliott.
The one factual difference in the instant case as compared to
Elliott, supra,
is that
Elliott
dealt with the power of referendum as contained in the home rule act
1
and the Charter of the City of Clawson, while the instant case deals with the power of initiative as contained in the home rule act and the Charter of the City of Livonia.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit