Wisconsin Supreme Court May 2, 1972, 105 (Anderson v. Anderson)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-05-1972

Hanley, J.

The sole issue presented upon this appeal is whether there is a defect in parties such that the demurrer was properly sustained.

There is no question but that all parties to the agreement are proper parties to this lawsuit. However, a complaint is not demurrable merely because proper parties are not before the court; the demurrer will be sustained only if necessary or indispensable parties have not been joined.

Elliott v. Indemnity Ins. Co.

(1930), 201 Wis. 445, 448, 230 N. W. 87;

Borde v. Hake

(1969), 44 Wis. 2d 22, 30, 170 N. W. 2d 768. If, as respondent alleges, a partnership was created by the agreement, all the partners are indispensable parties and must be joined.

De

*669

Wit v. Lander

(1888), 72 Wis. 120, 39 N. W. 349;

Karp v. Coolview of Wisconsin, Inc.

(1964), 25 Wis. 2d 299, 304, 305, 130 N. W. 2d 790.

The burden of proving the existence of a partnership rests with respondent.

Morris v. Resnick

(1955), 268 Wis. 410, 415, 67 N. W. 2d 848. Sec. 178.03 (1), Stats., defines the term partnership as “an association of 2 or more persons to carry on as co-owners a business for profit.” The receipt of a share of those profits is deemed prima facie evidence that a person is a partner in the business. Sec. 178.04 (4). However, under sec. 178.04 (2), a partnership will not be implied merely because of common ownership of property, whether or not profits are shared by the co-owners.

Schleicker v. Krier

(1935), 218 Wis. 376, 379, 261 N. W. 413. As stated in 68 C. J. S.,

Partnership,

p. 435, sec. 20 c (2) :

“A mere community of interest in property, such as exists between tenants in common or joint tenants of real or personal property, does not make such owners partners or raise a presumption that a partnership exists, and this is so even though they cooperate in making improvements on their property and in realizing and sharing the profits or the losses and expenses arising therefrom.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.