Nebraska Supreme Court March 31, 1972, 38377 (Wulf v. FARM BUREAU INSURANCE COMPANY)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-03-1972

Newton, J.

This is an action on an insurance policy brought to recover windstorm damages. As a defense, defendant pleaded the statute of limitations and a separate trial was requested on that issue as provided for in section 25-221, R. S. Supp., 1971. The trial court resolved the issue in favor, of plaintiff and defendant appeals without awaiting trial of other issues or the entry of final judgment.

The case is now before us on plaintiff’s motion to dismiss the appeal grounded on the fact that a final judgment or determination of the case has not been entered. We sustain the motion.

The statute above referred to provides: “If the issue raised by the statute of limitations is. finally determined in favor of the plaintiff the remaining issues shall then be tried. If the issue raised by the statute of limitations is finally determined in favor of the defendant the action or actions barred by the statute of limitations shall be dismissed.” Defendant contends that the words “finally determined” import such a final determination of the issue presented on the statute of limitations that an immediate appeal is required if the right to a determination of the issue in the Supreme Court is to be preserved.' We do not believe that this is the legislative intent. The statute itself indicates that if the defendant’s plea is upheld, a further

order of dismissal

must be entered. This indicates the determination of the issue is interlocutory in nature and not to be considered as a final order warranting an appeal.

We have repeatedly held that: “All statutes relating

*260

to the same subject should be construed and considered together for the purpose of giving effect to the legislative intention. All statutes in pari materia must be considered together and construed as if they were one law, and, if possible, effect given to each provision.” State ex rel. Retchless v. Cook, 181 Neb. 863, 152 N. W. 2d 23.

Section 25-1911, R. R. S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.