District Court, N.D. Ohio November 7, 1972, Civ. A. C 68-462 (MIDLAND-ROSS CORPORATION v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1972

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

WILLIAM K. THOMAS, District Judge.

Plaintiff, Midland-Ross Corporation, as transferee and successor of Surface Combustion Corporation, sues for a refund of federal income taxes paid as a result of the disallowance of a deduction by the District Director of certain business expenses paid in connection with the sale, upon liquidation, of Surface’s assets to Midland, and a further disallowance of a depreciation deduction taken by Surface. As to a gain of Surface in the sale of its assets to Midland, the Government claims income tax is due while Midland asserts non-recognition under 26 U.S.C. § 337. This remaining issue is raised by the Government’s affirmative defense of set off because the statute of limitations on further assessment of income taxes against Midland, as transferee of Surface, for the calendar year 1959 has expired.

Subsequent to the filing of the complaint the parties stipulated that the business expenses were not proper deductions and the United States has now acknowledged that the disallowance of the depreciation deduction was erroneous. The affirmative defense, if sustained, would produce an. income tax indebtedness of Surface that would exceed the amount of refund to which Midland, as transferee, is eoncededly entitled.

Sometime prior to November 9, 1959, Surface adopted a plan of complete liquidation and within 12 months thereafter, by a sale of its assets to Midland, Sur

*1289

face completely liquidated its business and distributed the assets (cash) to its stockholders. Midland assumed all of the liabilities, including tax liabilities, of Surface.

Part of the property purchased by Midland was long term uncompleted, but partially performed, contracts entered into by Surface with various purchasers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.