District of Columbia Court of Appeals March 15, 1972, 6000 (McKnight v. Wire Properties, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1972
FICKLING, Associate Judge:
Appellant appeals from an order of the trial court granting appellees’ motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
1
We affirm.
*406
At about 9 p. m. on April 9, 1969, appellant tripped and fell down a flight of stairs located in the apartment building where she lived. Appellant testified that she left her apartment, located on the second floor of the premises, and began to descend the stairs to the first floor. She stepped off the landing with her right foot on the first step, then brought her left foot down to the second step, when “something caught my shoe heels, both of them, and pitched me forward down the steps.” After her fall appellant observed that both shoes were caught in the grooves on the tread of the second step. The shoes were described as “walking heels” as opposed to “spike heels.” The vertical portion of the step, the riser, is 6% inches high; the horizontal portion, the tread, is 10% inches wide. The front 3% inch portion of the step contains three corrugations or grooves, each in the shape of a hemisphere of an inch wide at the top and %6 of an inch deep. The steps are concrete with the metal grooves embedded flush with the horizontal surface.
Appellant further testified that the stairs were illuminated by a 40-watt bulb on the ceiling above the second floor landing— nine feet above the landing, and another 40-watt bulb on the ceiling of the first floor landing. She also stated that she had lived in the building for over six months and had ascended and descended the same stairs at least once a day during that period without difficulty.
The Superintendent of Maintenance testified for the owner that there were 25 buildings in the 101-building apartment complex with stairways identical to the ones on which appellant fell, and that he had no knowledge of anyone’s ever having fallen on the steps on which appellant fell or on similarly constructed steps in the other buildings.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit