District of Columbia Court of Appeals December 28, 1972, 6529 (United States v. Hector)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-12-1972
HARRIS, Associate Judge:
On March 13, 1972, a two-count indictment was filed in the Superior Court, charging appellee with burglary in the second degree and grand larceny. At a status hearing on May 19, 1972, the trial court heard argument with respect to a motion which had been filed by appellee’s counsel. In part, that motion urged that the indictment be dismissed. At the conclusion of the hearing, the motion to dismiss was granted. We reverse and remand, thus reinstating the indictment.
A threshold jurisdictional question is presented. Since the dismissal of the indictment created no bar to the seeking of a
*505
new indictment by the Government, it is argued on behalf of appellee that the prosecution was not terminated by the dismissal order and hence that the order is not reviewable. Such a contention is without merit. D.C.Code 1967, § 23-104(c) (Supp. V, 1972) provides:
The United States or the District of Columbia may appeal an order dismissing an indictment or information or otherwise terminating a prosecution in favor of a defendant . . . except where there is an acquittal on the merits.
Such language is unambiguous. Additionally, it is obvious that an order dismissing an indictment or an information terminates a prosecution in the sense that such an order completely severs the ties of the criminal justice system with the accused. He immediately becomes entitled to discharge from bail or custody. Although that severance may be only temporary (as here where the dismissal was without prejudice and the charges may be brought again
1
), the requisite attributes of finality are present and the order is appealable under D.C.Code 1967, § 11-721 (Supp. V, 1972).
2
The difficulties in this case arise from the fact that the complaining witnesses (and the defendant as well) are members of Washington’s Spanish-speaking community. Appellee was arrested on the basis of an identification by an eyewitness to (and victim of) the alleged burglary and larceny.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit