Court of Chancery of Delaware November 17, 1972 (Tri State Mall Associates v. A. A. R. Realty Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1972

SHORT, Vice Chancellor:

This is an action for specific performance of a contract for the sale of land. Pursuant to an order of the court dated July 28, 1971, settlement under that contract was made on August 16, 1971. The court at that time reserved jurisdiction over the question of the alleged obligation of defendant to compensate plaintiff for damages due to delay in settlement and to reimburse plaintiff for counsel fees. This is the decision after trial on those issues.

*370

The agreement of sale under which plaintiff sought and received specific performance and now seeks additional damages and counsel fees was entered into by plaintiff

1

and defendant A.A.R. Realty Corporation (A.A.R.), a Delaware corporation, on May 28, 1971. Under the terms of that agreement A.A.R. agreed to sell plaintiff a shopping center located in Brandywine Hundred, New Castle County, known as “Tri State Mall,” subject to a first mortgage to be obtained by A.A.R. from Mutual Insurance Company of New York (MONY) under a then-existing commitment. Of the $9,525,000 total purchase price, $7,100,000 was to be provided by the MONY mortgage, which by its terms would close on the same date set for settlement under the agreement of sale, July 7, 1971, with the balance to be paid in cash. It was also agreed that, simultaneously with settlement, plaintiff would lease the shopping center back to A.A.R. on a long-term basis.

On approximately June 10, 1971, A.A.R. informed plaintiff of the existence of a letter agreement entered into with MONY on March 16, 1971, under which MONY now asserted the right to purchase, concurrently with the closing of the first mortgage, the fee interest in the property for an amount some $925,000 less than that offered by plaintiff. MONY sought to compel A.A.R.’s performance under the “agreement” by threatening to withdraw from its mortgage commitment unless the shopping center property was conveyed to it. Although neither plaintiff nor A.A.R. were of the opinion that A.A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.