Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit January 4, 1972, 71-1223, 71-1224 (Lakewood Manufacturing Company v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-01-1972

KENT, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal by the Taxpayer from an adverse decision by the Tax Court.

1

The Taxpayer is a corporation, the stock of which is held by Stephen Peplin and the members of his family. The Taxpayer contests deficiencies in corporate income tax found by the Commissioner resulting from the Commissioner’s determination that for the tax years ending May 31, 1962 through May 31, 1967, the salary deducted by the Taxpayer for compensation paid to Stephen Peplin as president was unreasonably high.

Effective June 1, 1959, Stephen Pep-lin was paid $60,000 as President of the company. One of his sons was paid $27,500 as Secretary of the company, and the other son was paid $27,500 as Treasurer of the company. On June 1, 1961, the salaries of the officers were changed. Stephen Peplin’s salary was fixed at $80,000 annually and the salaries of his sons were fixed at $32,500. On January 1, 1967, the salaries were again adjusted; Stephen Peplin’s salary was fixed at $60,000, and the salaries of his sons were fixed at $40,000. As shown, the sales and profits

2

of the company each increased substantially until a disastrous fire occurred on October 3, 1961. The dividends paid were as follows;

Upon review of the Taxpayer’s tax returns for the years in question the Commissioner determined, among other things, that for each of the taxable years ending May 31, 1962 through May 31, 1967, the salary paid to Stephen Pep-lin was unreasonably high, and determined further that the Taxpayer should not be allowed to deduct more than $60,000 of the salary paid to Stephen Peplin as a business expense for the years in question.

On the trial before the Tax Court only three witnesses were called for the Taxpayer and none for the Government. The Taxpayer called Stephen Peplin, President, one of his sons, Richard Pep-lin, Secretary of the corporation, and a management consultant, Mr. Richard M. Walker.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.