Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit April 24, 1972, 24945 (Joseph A. Yablonski v. United Mine Workers of America)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-04-1972

PER CURIAM:

Last July 21 we held that a law firm retained by the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) could not continue as its counsel in this case.

1

We did so because we found, in the firm’s past and ongoing representation of UMWA’s president in other litigation, the potential for conflict with obligations owing UMWA in this litigation.

2

In due course our mandate

3

issued to vacate the District Court’s denial of a motion to disqualify the firm, and to remand the ease for further proceedings in accordance with our opinion.

4

Thereupon, the firm .promptly withdrew, and UMWA’s general counsel and all four members of his staff entered appearances on behalf of UMWA. Appellants immediately moved the District Court for an order disqualifying them, and the motion was denied. Appellants return here on a petition for further relief, characterizing the District Court’s ruling as a failure to give full effect to the mandate.

5

We agree, and accordingly grant the petition.

I

We confront, at the outset, appellees’ objection that we lack jurisdiction to

*1038

consider the petition. It is contended that the District Court’s order refusing disqualification of UMWA house counsel was interlocutory and, as such, non-appealable;

6

and the record, it is argued, does not show a clear and indisputable right to extraordinary relief under the All Writs Act.

7

Appellants, on the other hand, charge that the order flies in the face of our earlier mandate, and that mandamus is available to correct the asserted departures.

8

We think the order now challenged was appealable, just as we felt its predecessor was on the prior appeal where, indeed, our jurisdiction was not seriously questioned.

9

The present situation differs, however, from the former because the instant order has not been subjected to an appeal.

10

Instead, appellants seek summary relief allegedly needed to exact compliance with the mandate, and the quest is valid if its underlying premise is.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.