Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit June 2, 1972, 71-1469 (G. L. Boone v. Royal Indemnity Company)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-06-1972
WILLIAM E. DOYLE, Circuit Judge.
In this case the plaintiff Boone sought to recover on a fire insurance policy which had been issued on a business property located in Atlanta, Georgia, which property was destroyed by an incendiary fire. The suit was first filed in the state court and was removed to United States District Court for the District of Colorado.
The policy covered the plant and equipment of Hickory Manor Portion Foods, Inc., of Georgia, which company was substantially (80 percent of the stock) owned by the plaintiff, G. L. Boone of Denver, Colorado. Some months before the fire there was an assignment of the policy from Hickory Manor to G. L. Boone, which occurrence explains his appearance as the sole plaintiff. The amount sought was $260,243.00. The insurance company interposed the defense of arson caused, procured or ratified by the plaintiff. Following submission of the case to a jury a defendant’s verdict was returned in favor of the Royal Indemnity Company.
On this appeal reversal is sought, first, on the contention of appellant that the evidence was insufficient to support the jury’s verdict; secondly, on his claim that the trial court was incorrect in dealing with burden of proof on the arson defense; and, further, the reception of some hearsay evidence.
G. L. Boone was shown by the evidence to have been engaged in the barbeque frozen food processing and merchandising business. He had plants in Denver and Atlanta and was engaged in other unrelated business ventures. The plaintiff’s brother, J. K. Boone, was the manager and part owner of the Atlanta plant and was also at the time in question the sole employee of that business. Plaintiff’s wife was secretary of both the Colorado and the Georgia corporations.
The evidence showed that at the time of the fire plaintiff was plagued with severe financial problems. Neither the Denver nor the Atlanta plants had shown any net profit for several years.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit