Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit March 16, 1972, 71-1844 (United States v. Lynwood Burley)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-03-1972
combined-opinion
460 F.2d 998 UNITED STATES of America v. Lynwood BURLEY, et al., Appellants. No. 71-1844. United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. Argued Jan. 3, 1972. Decided March 16, 1972. David H. Kubert, Philadelphia, Pa., for appellant. Carmen C. Nasuti, Asst. U. S. Atty., Philadelphia, Pa., (Louis C. Bechtle, U. S. Atty., Philadelphia, Pa., on the brief), for appellee. Before HASTIE and MAX ROSENN, Circuit Judges, and McCUNE, District Judge. OPINION OF THE COURT HASTIE, Circuit Judge. 1 On this appeal from a conviction of bank robbery, it is contended that reversible error appears in the trial judge's supplementary charge to the jury. 2 During the course of its deliberation the jury sent two written communications to the judge. The first read: "It appears that we cannot arrive at any decision in this case. We have one member who refuses to enter into deliberation on the basis that all of the witnesses are not to be believed." The second note read: "The same juror still states that she has doubts that the defendants were the men in the bank and also doubts other parts of the testimony. The remaining jurors cannot carry on effective deliberation due to this unyielding attitude. The question seems to revolve on her understanding of 'reasonable doubt.' Any helpful suggestion would be appreciated." 3 With the matter in this posture and after the jury had been out for about four hours, the trial judge had the jury returned to the courtroom where he gave the challenged supplementary instructions. 4 First, the judge repeated his clearly correct charge on "reasonable doubt." Next, he summarized the testimony of the witnesses who had identified the defendants as the robbers and in so doing indicated, inferentially at least, that to him the identification testimony seemed strong and persuasive. Finally, the court said this to the jury: 5 "Another thing you should bear in mind is this: If this jury cannot agree, the case is going to have to be tried again.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit