Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit May 16, 1972, 71-1600 (Theodore R. Smith v. Walter E. Coy, Trading and Doing Business as Coy Brothers)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-05-1972

OPINION OF THE COURT

PER CURIAM:

This is an appeal from an order of the District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania denying defendant’s motion for a new trial in this diversity tort action. The case arose from a “rear end” collision between plaintiff’s automobile and a tractor trailer on February 23, 1967. The accident occurred in Pennsylvania, and Pennsylvania law applies. The jury returned a verdict in favor of plaintiff in the sum of $25,000. We affirm.

This appeal questions not the conclusion of negligence — which, indeed, it would seem impossible to dispute — but rather (1) the district court’s instructions as to damages, and (2) the amount awarded to the plaintiff.

The primary contention as to the instructions on damages concerns an instruction which was given by the district court at the request of the plaintiff. No objection was taken by the defendant to it. The instruction in its entirety read:

In determining the damages to be awarded for impairment of earning capacity, you may consider the trade or occupation of the plaintiff and whether, as a result of the accident, he is still able to pursue this trade or occupation. That point is affirmed.

Since counsel for the defendant did not take exception to this charge, we consider only whether it was plain error. McNello v. John B. Kelly, Inc., 283 F.2d 96, 102 (3d Cir. 1960). We hold that it was not.

Standing alone, the instruction quoted above for impairment of earning capacity might be inadequate for it would not include an instruction that loss of earning capacity must be reduced to present worth, and because actuarial data was not supplied so as to enable the jury to reduce the award to present worth. Haddigan v. Harkins, 441 F.2d 844 (3d Cir. 1970).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.