Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit February 17, 1972, 21573, 21755 (Jeannette Lenkin v. District of Columbia, Morris Pollin v. District of Columbia)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-02-1972
SPOTTSWOOD W. ROBINSON, III, Circuit Judge:
These two cases, consolidated in this court, present similar fact patterns and similar issues for our consideration. In each, the assets of a dissolved corporation, consisting chiefly of an apartment building, were distributed, subject to outstanding corporate debts, to its stockholders who promptly discharged the indebtedness and continued, through the medium of a newly-formed partnership, the preexisting corporate business of operating the facility. In each, deductions for depreciation on the apartment property, taken on partnership returns filed under the District of Columbia Income and Franchise Tax Act of 1947,
1
were administratively disallowed, almost totally, as resting upon an improper depreciation basis. In one case, the property’s alleged fair market value on liquidation and, in the other, what essentially was its book value at that point, were rejected as appropriate bases; in both, the depreciation base administratively substituted excluded the amount of corporate indebtedness existing at the time of liquidation. The courts whose reviews preceded ours have substantially upheld the administrative determinations.
So, once again, we are called upon to construe provisions of the Income and Franchise Tax Act, but perhaps for the very last time. During the pendency of this appeal,
2
the Act was amended to important respects
3
and the problems now posed will not recur.
4
During the same period, the course of judicial review of District Tax assessments was legislatively altered,
5
and such reviews no longer come to this court.
6
Since, however, these changes are inapplicable to the litigation at hand,
7
we proceed to our task.
I
While factually these cases share much in common, there are differences which must be accounted for in any decision of the questions raised. Our review accordingly begins with a summary of the relevant developments in each.
The Lenkin Case
Lencshire House, Inc.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit