Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit June 16, 1972, 71-1659 (Melvin Kahle, Administrator of the Estate of Adella Curry v. Glosser Brothers, Inc)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-06-1972

OPINION OF THE COURT

PER CURIAM:

This is an appeal by Melvin Kahle, administrator of the estate of Adella Curry, from an order of the District Court, 326 F.Supp. 985, granting appellee Glos-ser Bros., Inc.’s motion for summary judgment in a suit brought by Kahle under the Wrongful Death and Survival Acts of Pennsylvania.

1

On April 3, 1967, decedent, Adella Curry, — a resident of West Virginia at the time of her death — and her daughter, Catherine Curry, were shopping in the Glosser store in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. After having selected various groceries and before arriving at the checkout counter, the daughter decided to return two items — namely, the butter and the cheese — to the shelves. She did so. The ladies paid for their other purchases, left the store and proceeded to their car in Glosser’s parking lot. As the daughter was entering the driver’s seat, Glosser’s female security officer grabbed her right arm and demanded the return of the butter and the cheese. Miss Curry replied that the items had been returned and invited the security officer to search her pockets and belongings. After so “searching” Miss Curry, the officer followed a similar procedure with the decedent, who had remained silent during this initial exchange. Nothing was discovered. Although the officer started to walk away, the daughter apparently prolonged the encounter, indicating in no uncertain terms what she thought of the detective’s unfounded accusations. A heated argument ensued between the two and while it was in progress, the mother — a few feet away and upset by the incident — fell to the ground and died instantly of a coronary occlusion. According to the treating

*817

physician, her death was a direct result of the general excitement of the event.

2

Until the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision in Niederman v. Brod-sky, 436 Pa. 401, 261 A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.