Court of Appeals for the First Circuit July 12, 1972, 72-1111 (Leslie S. Ray Insurance Agency, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-07-1972

ALDRICH, Chief Judge.

This is an action brought in the district court to recover alleged over-payments of income tax. Plaintiff taxpayer testified by deposition of its president and sole stockholder, one Ray. The government offered Ray’s deposition and certain purchase and sales contracts, and moved for summary judgment of dismissal. This the court granted, and taxpayer appealed. Believing that no construction of the evidence warrants recovery, we affirm.

Taxpayer conducts a general insurance agency business from offices located in Beverly, Massachusetts. In 1962 and 1964 it purchased the only two agencies in nearby Hamilton, thereby hoping to corner the Hamilton insurance market. The price in both instances was computed by a “general rule of thumb,” roughly at three times the gross annual commissions of the selling agency. In addition, the sellers agreed not to compete within the area, in one case for ten years and in the other for five. The purchase documents assigned no specific or separate monetary consideration for these agreements.

In its returns taxpayer sought to allocate a substantial (but different in the two cases) percentage of the purchase price to the agreements not to compete, and claimed annual deductions representing the amortization of the amounts it had allocated. The Commissioner disallowed the deductions, asserting that no part of the purchase price was properly allocable to the non-compete agreements. Taxpayer paid the additional assessments and brought this suit.

In dismissing the complaint, without opinion, the district court cited Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Danielson, 3 Cir., 1967, 378 F.2d 771. Taxpayer says that

Danielson

was wrongly decided. We need not, however, choose be

*212

tween

Danielson

and the view of the circuits which do not follow it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.