Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit August 10, 1972, 72-1056 (Richard Maddox v. Elliot L. Richardson, Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-08-1972

McCREE, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal from the dismissal of a complaint seeking review of a decision of the Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare denying disability benefits.

Appellant claims that he became disabled from work in 1955 because of a back injury. It is not disputed that his special earnings requirement expired on June 30, 1960. He has filed five applications for benefits, the fifth of which is before this court. The four earlier applications were made without the aid of counsel and, in each earlier case, appellant failed to request a hearing on his application after its denial by the Social Security Administration. He requested reconsideration only of the denial of the fourth application; and, upon reconsideration, it, too, was denied on August 20, 1966. No further appeals have been taken from any of the four earlier applications.

This application, which was accompanied by two medical reports not previously submitted, was filed on June 4, 1969, with the aid of counsel. Counsel for appellant now asserts that

[appellant] having been unrepresented prior to this application, proper

*618

medical evidence had not been submitted supporting his claim and counsel therefore submitted additional medical evidence clearly constituting new and material evidence under the Social Security Regulations and grounds for “good cause” for reopening plaintiff’s earlier applications.

When this application was denied, a hearing was requested for the first time.

The hearing examiner denied the request for a hearing on the ground that the issues raised by the application were res judicata, and he refused to reopen the prior determinations in the case. He stated:

Section 404.937 of the Social Security Administration’s Regulations No. 4 (20 CFR 404.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.