Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit November 10, 1972, 79, Docket 72-1481 (United States v. Jose Francisco San Martin)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1972
OAKES, Circuit Judge:
This appeal from a narcotics conviction
1
raises interesting questions regarding use of a wiretap. It is necessary to summarize the evidence briefly to put the wiretap issues in context.
Through an intermediary (Nicolay), appellant made arrangements in Montevideo with one Gonzalez to smuggle into the United States some “Golden Watches” which later turned out to be 155 pounds of heroin. Nicolay delivered four suitcases and an attache case full of “watches” to Gonzalez who flew with them to Panama. Gonzalez’ nephew Richard, who had a diplomatic passport because his father was Panamanian ambassador to Formosa, with a friend took Braniff fight #906 with the suitcases checked through to Kennedy Airport in New York. A case of nerves, a visitor’s rather than a diplomat’s visa, and the weight of the suitcases triggered the skepticism of a customs officer, with the result that Richard’s diplomatic-passport gambit did not permit him to clear customs check-free. The suitcases were inspected and the golden watches turned into white “snow.” Richard, caught red-handed, agreed to cooperate with the customs agents who rented a room adjoining his at the Hotel McAlpin from which, with Richard’s consent, they “bugged” his telephone.
Gonzalez came to New York and to the McAlpin the following day, telling a taxi driver (who not by chance was really a customs agent) that he had a “friend” at the Edison Hotel but that he wanted to go to the McAlpin. When he arrived he walked right into the customs agents’ skillfully laid trap by going to Richard’s room and calling appellant at the Edison on the “bugged” phone to set up a rendezvous for an hour later at the Edison bar. Gonzalez was then arrested and,
without being told by anyone about the “bug,”
agreed to cooperate. The agents accordingly put the bags of heroin in a rental car parked in the APCOA garage at Broadway and 32nd Street and kept an eye on the bait for the new trap.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit