Connecticut Superior Court June 12, 1972, File No. 75019 (Fitzgerald v. Lawhorn)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-06-1972

The defendant assaulted the plaintiff by shooting him with a gun and wounding him. As a result, the plaintiff suffered personal injuries and incurred expenses for hospital care and medical and surgical treatment. The plaintiff seeks damages from the defendant for this assault upon him. The defendant admits the factual allegations in the plaintiff's complaint but has pleaded certain special defenses. These defenses allege that the defendant at the time of the assault upon the plaintiff was incompetent to stand trial and in the criminal proceedings which followed as a result of the shooting was adjudged not guilty by reason of insanity, and therefore was incapable of forming the intent necessary to ground an action for assault. Also, the defendant was under the insane delusion that the plaintiff was assaulting him and that the plaintiff was not a person, and therefore lacked the intent necessary to ground an action for assault. The parties have submitted this matter by stipulation and have stipulated that in the event of a judgment in favor of the plaintiff against the defendant the damages are to be assessed at $2500 without costs. The defense in this case is insanity. The majority view appears to be that an insane person should be liable for torts of negligence. Prosser, Torts (3d Ed.), p. 1030. The general rule at common law, subject to certain qualifications, is that an insane person is civilly liable for injuries resulting from an *Page 513 assault or battery committed by him. Note, 77 A.L.R.2d 625, 626. One reason for the rule appears to be that insane individuals usually have been classed with infants and held liable for their torts. This rule seems to have originated in a dictum in a case decided in 1616. Weaver v. Ward, Hob. 134, 80 Eng. Rep. 284. Another reason given is that where one of two innocent persons must suffer a loss, it should be borne by the one who occasioned it. Note, 51 A.L.R. 833, 835.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.