Ohio Court of Appeals February 1, 1972, 71-356 (City of Hilliard v. Miller)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-02-1972
Troop, P. J.
Julian Miller was arrested by a police officer of the city of Hilliard for the violation of a city ordinance (Section 135.02, Hilliard Code), which offense carried a possible maximum fine of $50. Counsel for Miller filed a jury demand with the clerk of the mayor’s court whereupon, under B. C. 2937.08, the case was certified to the Municipal Court of Franklin County. At the time of pretrial in the municipal court, the city of Hilliard objected to the jurisdiction of the court and later filed a motion to remand the cause to the mayor’s court of the city of Hilliard. The motion was overruled and the jury demand of the defendant granted.
This appeal is from the overruling of the motion of the city of Hilliard and the assertion of jurisdiction by the municipal court.
Included in the half-sheet entry of the municipal court, dated September 10, 1971, is the statement: “Case does justify jury trial based upon
State
v.
Smith,
33 Abs 272,
&
Sec 2947.23 OBC * * *.”
Ohio has been on record as opposed to imprisonment for debt for many years, which is a facet of some of the later cases concerning the assessments for costs in criminal matters. One early case,
The Second National Bank of Sandusky
v.
Becker
(1900), 62 Ohio St. 289, reflects the position of Ohio courts. It is interesting because it covers the contempt finding of a court in a civil matter involving a judgment and costs. It is noted in later decisions.
An Ohio Supreme Court decision in
Symons
v.
Eichelberger
(1924), 110 Ohio St. 224, states, at page 238: “Costs are not at the present time considered as punishment.” A court of appeals decision in the case of
City of Toledo
v.
Bader
(1937), 58 Ohio App. 143, is squarely in point. The rule set out in the second paragraph of the syllabus is as follows:
“The costs in a trial do not constitute a part of the
*165
fine so as to make an offense penalized at fifty dollars require a jury trial under Section 13443, General Code.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit