Tennessee Supreme Court March 6, 1972 (Knoxville Poultry & Egg Co. v. Robinson)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-03-1972
OPINION
CRESON, Justice.
This is the second time that the instant case has been before us 'n appeal. It involves a Workmen’s Compensation suit filed by Ruby Evelyn Robinson against her employer, Knoxville Poultry & Egg Company, Inc. The employer is again appealing from an adverse judgment of the Circuit Court of Knox County, Division 3, award*516ing Mrs. Robinson benefits under the Workmen’s Compensation law.
In this Opinion the parties will be referred to as they appeared in the trial court; that is, Ruby Evelyn Robinson as petitioner, and Knoxville Poultry & Egg Company, Inc. as defendant.
The pleadings in the present record are identical to those dealt with in the former opinion in the instant case, released on March 2, 1970, and reported at 224 Tenn. 124, 451 S.W.2d 675.
The cause was originally heard on August 25, 1969. The trial court rendered judgment in favor of petitioner and awarded her benefits for 25% permanent partial disability to the body as a whole. Defendant seasonably perfected an appeal-in-error to this Court. The trial court was reversed, and the cause remanded to the Circuit Court of Knox County for retrial. In doing so it was said:
“In this cause we are again confronted with an impossible task of decision. This is ascribable to the fact that this record is simply devoid of competent evidence as to (1) whether or not the malady complained of by petitioner had its origin and cause in a hazard incident to her employment; and (2) whether that malady is to be medically considered as an essential part or parcel or closely related, in a causal sense, to one of the specified compensable occupational diseases.
We are not content to determine the rights and liabilities, if any there be, of the parties to this cause without pertinent medical evidence directed to the above-mentioned factors.”
The facts of the present record are identical with those of the previous record with the exception of the deposition of Dr. William Swann.
Dr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit