Court of Appeals of Kentucky September 22, 1972 (City of Georgetown v. Mulberry)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-1972

CULLEN, Commissioner.

For many years, the office of chief of police of Georgetown, a fourth-class city, was an elective office. On January 2, 1969, the city council adopted an ordinance making the office an appointive one, effective at the end of the current term of the office on the first Monday in January of 1970. Under KRS 95.720 the city council had the authority to take such action. See Cawood v. Hensley, Ky., 247 S.W.2d 27.

Notwithstanding the above ordinance, the incumbent chief of police, Lewis Mulberry, proceeded to seek the Democratic nomination for the office at the primary in May 1969, and being successful in that venture, ran unopposed for and was elected to the office at the regular election in November 1969. (The county clerk, responsible for listing the offices to be voted for, and the candidates for those offices, at the primary and general elections, treated the office as still being an elective one.)

Mulberry knew of the ordinance and he had received an opinion of the Attorney General of Kentucky that the city council had authority to enact such an ordinance, but he was of the opinion that the ordinance might not have been passed in a procedurally valid way.

The members of the city council knew of Mulberry’s campaigning for nomination and election to the office, that he claimed some ground of invalidity of the ordinance, and that the county clerk was treating the office as one still to be voted for, but the council took no action to stop the election.

In January 1970 Mulberry claimed the office but the city council rejected his claim and appointed another person to the office. Mulberry then brought the instant action against the city, claiming the right to the office and its emoluments. The circuit court, being of the opinion that the city was estopped to rely on the ordinance, entered judgment upholding Mulberry’s claim. The city has appealed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.