New York Court of Appeals December 28, 1972 (Lascaris v. Wyman)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-1972

Chief Judge Fuld.

We are called upon to decide whether persons on strike may obtain public assistance if they are “ unable to maintain themselves ” within the sense of section 131 of the Social Services Law and otherwise comply with the provisions of that statute.

For over 20 years the Commissioner of Social Services of the State of New York, in administering section. 131, has provided such assistance.1 Challenged in 1969 by the Commissioner of the Department for Social Services of Onondaga County (John L. Lascaris) on the ground that subdivisions 1 and 4 (of § 131) rendered striking workers ineligible for public assistance, the. State Commissioner’s administrative practice was accorded judicial approval. (Lascaris v. Wyman, 61 Misc 2d 212, 215 [herer *390after referred to as Lascaris 7].) 2 No appeal was taken from that decision. Subsequently, in 1971, the Legislature, unquestionably aware of the State Commissioner’s long-established administrative policy, passed an amendment to subdivision 4, elaborating upon the statute’s definition of an “ employable ” person.3 As indicated, the question posed on this appeal, here as *391of right, is whether under subdivision 4, as amended in 1971, the State Commissioner may continue to make public assistance grants available to otherwise qualified persons on strike.

The present case — and the facts are substantially undisputed — stems from a strike, begun in the summer of 1971, by the Communication Workers of America against the New York Telephone Company and other employers. Although the national union soon reached a settlement with the employers, the locals in this State — Locals 1123, 1152, 1191 and 1197, affiliated with the Greater Syracuse Labor Council — refused to ratify it and continued to strike until February, 1972.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.