Ohio Supreme Court February 9, 1972, No. 71-95 (Westwood v. Thrifty Boy Super Markets, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-02-1972

Schíteidee, J.

The question before us is whether the defense of assumption of risk is available to an “employer,” as defined in R. C. 4101.01(C),1 in an action against him brought by a “frequenter,” as defined in R. C. 4101.-01(E),2 alleging a violation of R. C. 4101.113, a safe-place statute. We hold that the defense is available and, therefore, affirm.

By statutory definition, “frequenter” embraces business invitee, and “employer” is equivalent to an owner or occupier of premises. Concededly, at the time of her injuries, appellant was on the premises of appellees as a frequenter or business invitee and appellees were the owner and occupier, respectively, of those premises.

R. C. 4101.11 is no more than a codification of the common-law duty owed by the owner or occupier of premises tó business invitees to keep his premises in a reasonably safe condition and to give warnings of latent or concealed perils *87of which he has, or should have, knowledge. Debie v. Cochran Pharmacy-Berwick (1967), 11 Ohio St. 2d 38, 42; Sidle v. Humphrey (1968), 13 Ohio St. 2d 45; Holdshoe v. Whinery (1968), 14 Ohio St. 2d 134. Furthermore, that the defense of assumption of risk was available at common law in an action by an invitee against an owner or occupier of premises cannot be seriously questioned. See Masters v. New York Central Rd. Co. (1947), 147 Ohio St. 293; Davis v. Charles Shutrump & Sons Co. (1942), 140 Ohio St. 89; Plas v. Holmes Construction Co. (1952), 157 Ohio St. 95; 39 Ohio Jurisprudence 2d 615 et seq., Section 80 et seq.

The first paragraph of the syllabus of Plas, approving and following Davis, both of which were decided long after the adoption of the predecessor of R. C. 4101.11, held:

“In an action by a contractor’s employee against a contractee for injuries resulting from the condition of the premises of the contractee . . . his assumption of the risks arising from those conditions constitute valid defenses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.