Ohio Supreme Court April 26, 1972, Nos. 71-249 and 71-418 (Masheter v. Blaisdell)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-04-1972

lead-opinion

Brown, J.

The sole issue raised in these cases is: In a highway appropriation proceeding where the Director of Highways has filed a Resolution and Finding to appropriate a perpetual easement in land for highway purposes, may a jury be permitted to consider more than the present intended use of the property, as established in the director’s Resolution and Finding, in assessing damages to the remainder (residue) of the property.

We affirm the judgments of the Court of Appeals.

In each case, the Resolution and Finding filed by the director was captioned a “Perpetual Easement for Highway Purposes” and contained a detailed description of the easement being appropriated. Neither the property dimensions nor the amount of property specified therein were disputed by the parties.

The landowners invite our attention to the fact that the director did not elect to limit, by the caption of his Resolution and Finding, the use of the perpetual easement for any specific highway purposes. They contend that this broad language used by the director could reasonably be construed to contemplate not only his present intended use of the land for highway purposes but also any potential future purposes to which the land can be put by the director. This view is reflected in the court’s special instructions, as requested by appellants, wherein the jury was charged that “the damages to the remainder of the property are not necessarily to be determined solely on the basis of the present intended use of the land taken by the Director of Highways for highway purposes or the present proposed location of the roadway slopes and ditches planned in the present reconstruction of State Route * * (Emphasis supplied.)

In a highway appropriation proceeding, the quality and quantity of rights taken from the landowner are estab*11lished by the Resolution and Finding, and plat filed by the Director of Highways. R. C. 5519.01.

In Masheter v. Diver (1969), 20 Ohio St.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.