Ohio Supreme Court December 6, 1972, No. 72-333 (Koch v. Kosydar)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-12-1972

Stern, J.

The Board of Tax Appeals, in reversing the assessment order of the Tax Commissioner, relied upon its interpretation of the syllabus in Machinery Moving v. Porterfield (1971), 26 Ohio St. 2d 99, which provides:

“The transfer of possession of bins and containers under refuse removal contracts is a personal service trans*77action, and involves only the transfer of tangible personal property as an inconsequential element, for which no charge is made, and such transfer is exempt from the sales tax under R. C. 5739.01(B).” Machinery Moving v. Porterfield, supra, is not controlling in the instant case.

It is not disputed that the cost of the equipment here involved is economically inconsequential when compared with the entire charge. However, economic inconsequentiality is not the sole determining factor. Recording Devices v. Porterfield (1972), 30 Ohio St. 2d 208, 211.

We look as well to the function of the equipment in regard to the overall service being provided. In Machinery Moving, the bins were inanimate objects. Both the bins and the subscribers involved there played only a minor role in the overall service transaction. A similar situation existed in American District Telegraph Co. v. Porterfield (1968), 15 Ohio St. 2d 92, which involved a central alarm system. In ADT, no function was performed by the subscribers and, although the alarm device did send a signal from the subscribers’ premises, that function was insignificant when compared to the substantial service performed by those offering the service..

In ADT, this court held that the alarms, by themselves, were useless, since the subscribers had sought protection of their property, which, the court said “comes only # * * when those companies [ADT] contact local authorities and send out their own guards.” The court stated further that ‘£ the equipment * * * may reasonably be viewed as only an aid in the rendering of protection service.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.