Supreme Court of Louisiana March 27, 1972, No. 51351 (State v. Armstrong)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1972

McCALEB, Chief Justice.

Leonard Armstrong was charged with the crime of attempted murder. He was convicted of having committed the crime of attempted manslaughter and sentenced to serve four years and three hundred and sixty-four days in the State Penitentiary. He is appealing from that conviction.1

In their brief to this Court defense counsel indicate that they are relying on three bills of exceptions reserved during the course of the trial to obtain a reversal of the conviction. However, our examination of the record reveals that it contains no bills of exceptions perfected in accordance with Article 845 C.Cr.P. In the record, and apparently relied on by counsel as a substitute for the formal bills, are notes in evidence taken during the trial in connection with the reservation of the respective bills of exceptions at that time.

*720Under such circumstances we cannot consider the alleged errors. Articles 844 and 920 C.Cr.P.2

An official Revision comment in connection with Article 843 C.Cr.P. (which sets forth the procedure for reserving a bill of exceptions during the course of the trial) states:

“ * * * It should be noted that the bill of exceptions is not reviewable on appeal unless it is incorporated in a formal bill of exceptions, which formal bill must be signed by the judge. There is considerable authority in the jurisprudence for the distinction between the ‘bill of exceptions’ and the ‘formal bill of exceptions.’ * * * ”

The comment made in connection with Article 844 recites that:

“(a) The first paragraph of this article states the well-settled general rule that bills of exceptions which are not perfected and signed by the trial judge are considered to be abandoned and may not be considered on appeal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.