Supreme Court of Colorado May 15, 1972, No. 25338 (In re Certain Rules of Court Announced September 27, 1971)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1972
MR. JUSTICE DAY
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This attempt to invoke the appellate jurisdiction of this Court under the novel caption herein involves an order of a Denver Juvenile Judge prescribing line-up procedures to be followed in Denver Juvenile Hall in a decision involving specific juveniles detained at the Hall.
The proceedings in Juvenile Court were commenced by the filing of a “Motion for Protective Orders for Relief in the Nature of Prohibition and for Relief in the Nature of an Injunction, as Amended.” The motion was initiated by the State Public Defender. The particular juveniles represented claimed their right not to be required to participate in a line-up in which there was no reasonable cause to believe that they were involved as suspects of the offense under investigation. Presented, inter alia, were two issues: 1. The rights and obligations of a juvenile suspect in a line-up. 2. The rights and obligation of a juvenile held in detention and selected as a “fill-in” in a line-up. Amicus Curiae briefs were received from the Denver City Attorney’s Office and the District Attorney’s Office on these questions. Additional comments were sought and received from the National Council on Crime and Delinquency, and from several juvenile courts in other jurisdictions.
Thereafter, the Honorable Philip B. Gilliam, Judge, entered a “Memorandum Opinion” holding,.inter alia, that a juvenile suspect is to be afforded the same rights as an adult with respect to line-up procedures. In addition, line-ups were authorized only upon order of the Juvenile Court. With regard to those juveniles held in Juvenile Hall and selected as “fill-ins,” the court held that they may refuse to participate, but that any one who agreed to participate would be granted immunity from prosecution for the particular offense with *270which the suspect is being investigated.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit