Court of Appeals of Maryland March 17, 1972, No. 223 (Waller v. Public Service Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-03-1972
Finan, J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The appellant, Harry Waller, is the owner of a 102 unit apartment complex and gasoline service station in Lexington Park, St. Mary’s County. While his sewage and water services were supplied by the Patuxent Water Company, Inc. (Patuxent), an appellee, his monthly rate was $8.50 for each unit. However, after the St. Mary’s County Metropolitan Commission (Metropolitan), another appellee, purchased Patuxent, Waller received a new schedule of rates wherein the charges rose as high as $20 to $25 per apartment unit. When Patuxent filed its application for the sale to Metropolitan with the Public Service Commission of Maryland (PSC), another appellee, the appellant along with others protested the approval raising many issues, some of which will be subsequently discussed. Being dissatisfied with the order of the PSC which approved the sale and with its affirmance by the Circuit Court of Baltimore City (Perrott, J.), to which court the case had been transferred for hearing, Waller appealed.
The main thrust of the appellant’s challenge to the orders of both the PSC and the court below is that the PSC *113excluded as irrelevant, evidence as to the reasonableness of the purchase price of $650,000 which Metropolitan paid to Patuxent for its property, assets and franchise. This objection was raised on the theory that the purchase price paid for Patuxent will eventually reflect itself in the rate base of Metropolitan and, if excessive, will inevitably result in unwarranted increases in water and sewage rates payable by Patuxent customers. See Pond, Public Utilities (4th ed.), § 450, at 791.
An issue was also raised regarding a per annum increase from $22,400 to $80,000 in the charge made by Metropolitan to Patuxent for treating the sewage of Patuxent. This latter item was the subject of litigation as the result of an equity suit filed by Metropolitan against Patuxent to collect these rates.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit